Return to Silent Hill director Christophe Gans has confirmed that an alternate, longer cut of the film exists, but there’s no guarantee this version will see the light of day.
That’s according to a fan who attended the Return to Silent Hill premiere and a Q&A session with Gans (via Reddit), who says the filmmaker originally submitted a longer version of the movie. Gans described this cut as longer and allowing the story more room to breathe, but he was instructed by his producers to trim the movie down to two hours. This version also gave a key character from Silent Hill 2–the game the movie is adapted from–more screen time and a death scene.
According to the fan, “Gans said he struggled to find the right place for it in the edit,” and it’s unclear if the scene will appear in a potential director’s cut version of Return to Silent Hill. The film has gotten off to a poor start at the box office, grossing just $3.2 million from US theaters. This pales in comparison to the opening US weekends for 2006’s Silent Hill ($20.2 million) and Silent Hill: Revelation ($8 million), and reviews have not been kind.
