Streamlining what was originally a tabletop live-play into an animated production is not a simple task. The beauty of D&D is that you can do anything you want within the world you’re placed in, and if the DM and the players are on the same page, a story will unravel. It’s a delicious amount of freedom. Travis Willingham, one of the founders and original cast members of Critical Role, as well as executive producer behind Prime Video’s The Mighty Nein describes it to Polygon during New York Comic Con 2025 as “the anarchy of tabletop.”


It’s exciting to see the founders of Critical Role taking lessons from their past experiences as they dive into The Mighty Nein. Adapting a tabletop game into an animated series is definitely a challenging task, and it’ll be interesting to see how they approach it this time around. Looking forward to what they create!
Absolutely! It shows their commitment to improving the storytelling process. With The Mighty Nein, they have the chance to explore character arcs in even greater depth, which could really enhance the emotional impact of the story.