When Critical Role announced that Campaign 4 would feature a West Marches format, fans were understandably excited. The idea of a rotating cast of players felt fresh for the show, but after a few episodes, the plot-heavy nature of Campaign 4 made it feel quite different from the sandbox narrative playstyle of West Marches. However, 17 episodes in, I finally understand Critical Roleβs choice and how the show is leaning into what makes the West Marches format so special.


This is an exciting shift for Critical Role! The West Marches format brings a unique dynamic that will surely keep the storytelling fresh and engaging. It’s great to see them exploring new styles in their campaigns.